Advertisement
Hi there - So my friend is a professional gardener and I'm hiring him to install CA native plants in my front yard to replace the lawn. He wants to spray Roundup to kill the grass; I want to stay chemical-free and told him I'd help him do the work of tearing out the lawn rather than use the spray. He swears that Roundup isn't THAT toxic and loses any toxicity by the time if gets into the groundwater. I'm skeptical. Does anyone know about this?
Thanks!
Thanks!
Advertisement
Advertisement
-
Re: Roundup question - getting rid of lawn
Wed, November 22, 2006 - 8:34 AMdon't support monsanto's ruination of the planet! they are a fucked company no matter how you slice it and Round-up was their entree into the general and unknowledgeable consumer world. (check out the scary documentary The Future of Food for some info about their ethics)
I remove lawns all the time with a mattock and some hard work. you can do it and all it takes is your labor. start at one edge with your feet in the lawn and your head facing an edge. get the mattock into the edge and use it to pull out the turf towards you. as you remove hunks of lawn, flip them over and let them stay exposed to sun/air to dry out a bit so that you can knock off as much of the impacted root soil as you can, to save the soil. it is waaaay worth the effort to have no chems at all and your native garden will thank you. in fact I'll thank you too for going native! you rock! -
-
Re: Roundup question - getting rid of lawn
Mon, November 27, 2006 - 4:04 PMThat's pretty much what I decided to do. Fuck Monsanto. But when I dug out my veggie patch in the back yard, the trick with flipping the lawn chunks over and letting them dry did NOT work at all. My soil is really clay-ey, and they just dried into impossible rocks. It's easier for me to shake the soil off when it's still wet.
What about rototilling the lawn and picking out the chunks? Last time I tore out a bunch of my lawn I messed up my hip.
What's a good substitute for lawn when you want something oyu can walk and sit on like a lawn, without all the watering/chemicalizing? -
-
Re: Roundup question - getting rid of lawn
Tue, November 28, 2006 - 8:53 AMyeah now that it is wet out it is harder to accomplish that part >> this is a good summer project 8^) and yeah clay soils----> I am in the bay area too, and it is possible but it is no cake walk, it is work.
is it sunny? then for sure Thymus pseudolanuginosus or Thymus serphyllum. I have made many many entire lawns out of wooly thyme and it freaking rocks!!!! no mowing, water until established, then perhaps monthly watering in hot weather. if its shady and sunny I like to mix it up with Blue Star Creeper also > Pratia angulata, or sometimes called Isotoma or Laurentia fluviatilis (damnable taxonomy!!)
rototilling is great if there is no buried pvc/metal irrigation (or you know For Sure how deep it is), and more importantly >> there are no surrounding trees or shrubs that you worry about damaging >>> remember that water-gathering roots easily travel 4x the diameter of the plant. -
-
Re: Roundup question - getting rid of lawn
Thu, November 30, 2006 - 4:20 PMAwesome. It's mostly sunny during the summer, partly sunny during winter.
-
Re: Roundup question - getting rid of lawn
Sat, December 2, 2006 - 4:46 PMok I re-read my post and realized that the groundcover suggestions were so NOT native!! If you would like to go native on a broad expanse it is nice to do a meadow restoration which takes time and persistence, and can consist of a varied mix of native annuals, perennials and grasses that do not get mowed.
-
-
Unsu...
Re: Roundup question - getting rid of lawn
Tue, December 5, 2006 - 1:22 PMSince your soil is pretty much clay, removing _any_ organic material seems kind of counter-intuitive. I'd seed it with alfalfa, let that grow up until the first flowers break, mow the entire thing, add any sand or lime or green sand, and then rototill the entire thing and solarize it for six months. Letting the alfalfa grow tall will weaken the grass by reducing its available light, mowing it at the first flowering of the alfalfa will prevent any seed bank from building (and also keep the time-span short enough that the grass doesn't have the chance to gather strength by growing above the fast-growing alfalfa). Also, a quick alfalfa crop will add _some_ nitrogen, but not a lot of nitrogen, which is important; you don't need much nitrogen, and too much is going to be a bad thing for native plantings (the weeds will benefit the most from excess nitrogen).
-
Re: Roundup question - getting rid of lawn
Wed, March 4, 2009 - 8:59 PMI know you've gotten many replies since your original post and maybe your lawn is ong gone right now, but for the sake of a post that many people read here it is
I've found that once scraped off the top, lawn makes for great layering in a compost pile soil chunks and all. If you let the grass die and some of the nitrogen burn off it acts as a really good brown matter and the chunks of soil are full of the microorganisms needed for a healthy compost pile.
Which brings me to the part about rototilling. running a rototiller through your topsoils really disturbs the micro organisms needed for healthy soils and plants. It's great if you have a large plot of land that hasn't been ammended for a while, but It has been advised against in any regular fashion
So there's my two cents, This is all on my mind right now as I am currently working on a very similar project for a highschool garden right now. Happy gardening to you
-
-
-
Unsu...
Re: Roundup question - getting rid of lawn
Fri, December 1, 2006 - 10:04 PMagreed round up is destroying everything we hold sacred -
-
Unsu...
Re: Roundup question - getting rid of lawn
Tue, December 5, 2006 - 1:25 PMThat is an inaccurate statement.
The improper use of RoundUp is problematic, but even that is not a long-term environtmental issue in most instances.
I would challenge anyone to back up these sweeping and overly-broad generalizations with some cold, hard facts that include accurate controls and unbiased studies.
-
-
Re: Roundup question - getting rid of lawn
Thu, December 14, 2006 - 4:17 PMI'm an organic garden designer/gardner in Los Angeles....and have removed quite a few St. Augustine lawns and replaced them with Native grass or plants....It is not a fun job to remove this stuff! and I won't ever guarantee it is gone forever....Here are some tips that help...Remove as much of the grass as possible...don't rototill now! (if you chop up the stuff your just spreading the roots around). Water thouroughly and let sit for two weeks.....Remove the grass and its roots a second time. (if you are blessed with time, do that several times). Then shut the water off.....Mulch heavily! and wait......until your satisfied....its all gone. Remember that St. Augustine roots.....can grow three feet deep....You'll never get it all out immediately! Roundup is dangerous stuff!.(read the label sometime and tell me you'd like that used near your family, pets and gardens) Somone mentioned solarizing...that works as well....but you need a complete cycle of seasons....lots of newspaper and black plastic. I've seen some amazing results with this method. I"m afraid its good old fashioned hard work thats going to get this stuff out!
-
Re: Roundup question - getting rid of lawn
Mon, January 22, 2007 - 12:45 PMIf you have not done it yet... Bioling water does a really good job of killing a lawn. Even works on the dreaded bermuda if you use enogh of it... -
-
Re: Roundup question - getting rid of lawn
Thu, June 7, 2007 - 10:00 AM<If you have not done it yet... Bioling water does a really good job of killing a lawn. Even works on the dreaded bermuda if you use enogh of it... >
Thank you thank you thank you!!! The bane of my existence right now is bermuda grass! When we moved it to my house the whole backyard (6000 sq ft) was all bermuda grass. We've got most of it under control, but it still pops up and I'm trying to find sustainable ways of getting rid of it. I found that the torch method doesn't work on it. I'll try boiling water.
-
-
Re: Roundup question - getting rid of lawn
Fri, March 30, 2007 - 10:19 AMHow big is this lawn area? If it is somewhat smaller, what about doing a modified lasagna gardening method and put down lots of newspaper /cardboard to smother the grass and then add some topsoil and then plant with what you want to plant with? I know lots of gardeners who just stake out a piece of lawn, start layering and they never have to weed or break ground.
Also in Oregon where I come from orginally, they have alot of turf farms. Though they have huge machines to cut the sod, you may want to use the phone book and see if there is anyone who rents smaller scale machines to do this. You could potentially put the sog on FreeCycle and even get it hauled away for you for free*S*
Oh man.. do not even start me on Monsanto.
tenzicut
www.downtotherootsmagazine.com -
-
Re: Roundup question - getting rid of lawn
Thu, June 7, 2007 - 10:08 AMyou can rent a sod cutter from any equipment rental place. We used one recently to take out some lawn for a new patio. They are hard work, but faster and easier than cutting out the turf yourself.
-
-
Re: Roundup question - getting rid of lawn
Thu, May 24, 2007 - 9:58 AMCovering it up with cardboard, and then throwing mulch over the cardboard works great. The cardboard composts, the grass dies, and you have happy worms and soil. No chemicals required. And yes Roundup is quite toxic. It probably wouldn't kill everything it is sprayed on if it wasn't...
--Jesse -
-
Re: Roundup question - getting rid of lawn
Wed, May 30, 2007 - 7:52 AMWhat Jesse said. It is called sheet mulching, and works great. Besides (unwaxed) cardboard, you can use newspapers (no glossy pages) or grocery bags/ bag paper. Cover it with mulch or compost of any type (they vary in their breakdown times, but all eventually end up in the same place) if possible at least 6 to 12 inches deep, which allows you to start planting, especially perennials. Shallower mulch will just mean you will have to wait to really plant, maybe a year or so, except for maybe some shallow-rooted annuals. In a year or so the sheet mulch has rotted and you have a lovely plantable garden.
Toby Hemenway's book, "Gaia's Garden: A Guide to Home-Scale Permaculture" discusses this technique. -
-
Re: Roundup question - getting rid of lawn
Thu, June 7, 2007 - 11:34 AMI have a question as to which kind of nasty grass I'm dealing with on my lawn: it puts out runners and spreads horizontally. My goal is eventually to get rid of it 100%, going w/ native shrubs and perennials, paths, fragrant drought resistant roses, and the like. Will probably do the cover/solarize/mulch thing mostly, a section at a time...but this grass is TOTALLY invasive. I hate it. -
-
Re: Roundup question - getting rid of lawn
Thu, June 7, 2007 - 12:55 PMSounds like Bermuda Grass. We rototilled and then covered the area with black plastic for a year. It's still popping up here and there. The main problem is that if you leave even the smallest piece of it when pulling, it will come back.
-
-
-
-
Re: Roundup question - getting rid of lawn
Tue, July 10, 2007 - 5:00 PMWell there are two options that I know of. One cover the grass with a thick cover like cardboard, carpet ect. Because no light, water, and oxygen will get to it it will die. If this will take too long you can use distilled vinegar. Mix it with water and spray it over the lawn. The acidity will become too high for anything to grow there. After a few rains it will go back to a more neutral level, or you can add limestone.
-
Re: Roundup question - getting rid of lawn
Mon, June 29, 2009 - 12:47 PMi think sheet mulch/lasagne gardeding is the best choice. it doesnt disturb soil, it adds nutrients, its less work, and you can create a more natural setting with swales, mounds, depressions for a variety of plant zones and to collect water by making the mulch thicker and thinner. a compost expert here in town working at a city operated yard waste composting facility said he can eliminate certain classes of poisons such as roundup thru the compost process and that it one of "easier" classes to eliminate. he has the finished soil tested. there are other classes of poisons such as ddt that are harder. i am not advocating for roundup and would never use it but i am just relaying what i heard. -
-
Re: Roundup question - getting rid of lawn
Mon, June 29, 2009 - 4:55 PMi found this site some time ago... while researching this very topic for a friend.
www.naturescountrystore.com/roundup/
I believe the "RoundUp" brand is now owned by "Scotts"... that said i doubt little in the way of ingredients has changed... so this may still be a viable source of information on the matter.
-
-
Re: Roundup question - getting rid of lawn
Wed, July 29, 2009 - 10:08 AMI'd use urea to kill off the grass ( or anything else.) it'll leave the soil rich in nitrogen which will wash out in a few rainstorms
